The Advent with Austen‘s readalong of Sense and Sensibility is being hosted by Yvann over at Reading Fuelled by Tea.
Summary of the novel here.
Let the great readalong begin! I’m looking forward to what everyone else has to say about Jane Austen’s first published novel. This is the second time I read S&S and it’s surprising how different if fells and how influenced I’ve been by the adaptations.
Just 9 chapters in and I’m already convinced that of all of Austen’s books, S&S is the one that benefits most from screen adaptations. She leaves a lot to our imagination and I missed scenes like the one where Margaret hides in the library, but I especially wanted to see more of Elinor and Edward’s relationship development. There’s a whole chapter with just one conversation of Mr. and Mrs. John Dashwood, but so far no exchanges between one of the book’s main couples.
Still, that chapter was great, so witty, so clever, so Austen! You could see she had fun writing it, but it was also very useful to help us understand the injustice suffered by the Dashwood women, Fanny’s meanness and John’s meekness.
These first chapters also set the scene for the sisters’ relationship: unity and deep affection, but also a conflict of conduct and values. I couldn’t help thinking how alone Elinor must have felt at times. Clearly Marianne and her mother are of one mind, and young Margaret is going the same way. It must be tough on Elinor to constantly be the family’s voice of reason, Super-Ego and bad-cop.
I thought that this time around (now that I’m older and wiser, you see?) I’d find Marianne more annoying, but again, I take my hat off to Austen for creating a character like her. She has everything to be an exasperating teen, but instead I find myself thinking that what we need is more people who think and live like her: intensely and in a world of superlatives. I don’t want Marianne to be taught a bitter-but-necessary lesson. I want her to find the man she wants at 16, who reads Cowper with due passion and has an immaculate character.
And maybe Austen thought the same. Maybe she was sorrowful about the dirty job that lay ahead, or Marianne wouldn’t have been such a great character.
Now, please imagine that I said something thoughtful about parenting in Austen’s books, or social mobility, while I continue to muse about how my own idea of the ideal man evolved.
See you all at the joint viewing of Bride and Prejudice this Sunday?
7 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 2, 2011 at 9:50 am
Jillian ♣
I always come up Marianne Dashwood in Jane Austen quizzes. 🙂
I ADORE this book.
December 2, 2011 at 9:54 am
readingwithtea
Totally agree. We do see Edward and Elinor exclusively vicariously at first, don’t we – through Marianne gossiping with Mrs Dashwood, through Elinor talking to Marianne…
December 2, 2011 at 9:55 am
Sense & Sensibility Readalong, Part I | Reading Fuelled By Tea
[…] Alex said, as you get older you expect to like Elinor more and Marianne less. While it is easy to feel […]
December 2, 2011 at 3:58 pm
Amanda
I also felt the loss of the library scene with Edward and Margaret, and to me (at least until now) Margaret doesn’t show herself in the book as much as she appears in the movie.
I have a bit of a double view on Marianne, I like her passionate personality and teenage spirit, but some of her reactions do irritate me. It’s just difficult to think bad of her in general for very long through the book.
December 3, 2011 at 1:03 pm
Sense & Sensibility Readalong I (Ch. 1-9) | Liburuak
[…] people have already said very clever things about Sense and Sensibility (either as part of the Advent with Austen readalong or […]
December 6, 2011 at 7:50 pm
faith hope & cherrytea
this was my first reading experience of S&S though many movie nites spent with Marianne Elinor et al… love the character development, but definitely disliking Fanny & John’s capitulation to her instead of keeping his promise to his father…
December 8, 2011 at 10:08 am
Alex
@Jillian: I would probably be Elinor. Or Mrs Jennings 😛
@readingwithtea: I’m hoping for more one-on-one dialogues between our lovers in the upcoming chapters!
@Amanda: Exactly, that’s why the movies gave me so much in this novel. I have to admit that now that I’ve read the following chapters that she’s starting to get on my nerves…
@faith hope & cherrytea: I do think Austen was experimenting with character development. But somehow I think that the opposing characters of the sisters is more important than their individual personalities. It’s their duo that’s essential to the story.