My bookclub was discussing the depthness of good children’s books, so we decided to leave our comfort zone and try The Butterfly Lion.
It’s a very short book, around 180 pages, and indeed, we quickly jumped from one topic to another, from the constant removal of parents in children’s books (Mary Poppins, Narnia, Harry Potter), to the art of taming lions or the legality of burying people outside cemeteries in different countries.
The story is about Bertie, who grew up in an isolated farm in Africa. There he rescues an orphaned white lion cub, who becomes his best friend until Bertie turns eleven and is sent to school in England. The lion is sold to the owner of a French circus, who promises to take good care of it, but Bertie vows that they will meet again.
It’s a perfect book to discuss in a class of 7-12 year-old, and will enter my especial list of Recommendations For Boys Who Don’t Like Reading: there are lions, a circus, a War and vivid descriptions of exotic African landscapes. But what makes The Butterfly Lion stand out from other children’s book is the melancholy that seeps through.
There’s this bitter-sweet feel to the book that grabbed me immediately (à la Up), and made me prepare for an unhappy ending that never materializes… or does it? I don’t usually deal with kids at work or socially, so I wonder what they’d make of the book or of the big twist in the end. Do they (even if intuitively) feel the sadness and longing, or do they get caught in the adventure of it all?
The Butterfly Lion is wonderfully written and for the first time it made me curious to pick up Morpurgo’s other famous book, War Horse. I’ve heard it in audiobook, spotlessly narrated by Virginia McKenna and Michael Morpurgo himself.
***
Other thoughts: Me, My Books and I, Book Steps, Read 2 Review (yours?)
5 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 28, 2012 at 7:55 pm
nymeth
I have read neither this nor War Horse, but I highly recommend another WW1 novel of his, Private Peaceful. The stage adaptation is wonderful too. It’s also a story with a surprising ending, with lots of emotional implications that adults might be in a better place to fully grasp, but I love that he trusts children to get something out of it, even if they’re not yet knowledgeable enough to see the full picture.
April 26, 2012 at 3:39 pm
Alex
Private Peaceful – duly noted!
March 28, 2012 at 9:09 pm
Beth DiIorio
Thank you for this great post. I’d not heard of The Butterfly Lion before, and after reading your review, I just forwarded it to the school librarian (i”m guessing she’ll love your descriptor “For Boys Who Don’t Like Reading.”
Beth 🙂
April 26, 2012 at 3:41 pm
Alex
Let me know if there were any positive feedback from the kids.
April 16, 2013 at 11:30 am
The Butterfly Lion book review | Book-Steps
[…] my son did and it is in my opinion an absolute gem to read and treasure. Read another review of The Butterfly Lion on ‘The Sleepless Reader’. Tags: animals, christian birmingham, michael […]